Latest may news

may

Bolton’s Attack on the International Criminal Court May Backfire

By feedproxy.google.com
Published On :: Thu, 20 Sep 2018 11:48:10 +0000

20 September 2018

Dr Max du Plessis SC

Associate Fellow, International Law Programme

The US national security advisor’s recent threats look damaging but they may in fact strengthen support for the ICC from other states.

2018-09-20-Bolton.jpg

John Bolton speaks to the Federalist Society on 10 September. Photo: Getty Images.

On 10 September, US National Security Advisor John Bolton used his first major speech since joining the White House to attack the International Criminal Court’s (ICC) potential investigation of American personnel in Afghanistan. The ‘American patriots’, as Bolton describes them, are being investigated for potential torture and ill-treatment of detainees, mostly in 2003 and 2004, during the United States-led invasion of the country.

Bolton has a long history of opposition to the ICC. Although the US signed the ICC Statute under president Bill Clinton, it was ‘unsigned’ by Bolton, then an under-secretary of state in the George W Bush administration.

And when the court first opened its doors in 2002, Bolton helped secure, in what he described on 10 September as one of his ‘proudest achievements’, around 100 bilateral agreements with other countries to prevent them from delivering US personnel to the ICC. Those agreements were often extracted under pressure, with the US threatening to cut off military and other aid to countries that refused to sign.

In recent years under the Obama administration, relations between the US and the ICC improved, and the US offered help and support to the court. Bolton’s attack is aimed at reversing those gains – with measures aimed directly at the court and its staff.

These include: (i) negotiating ‘even more binding, bilateral agreements to prohibit nations from surrendering US persons to the ICC’; (ii) banning ICC judges and prosecutors from entering the US, sanctioning their funds in the US financial system and prosecuting them in the US criminal courts (and doing the ‘same for any company or state that assists an ICC investigation of Americans’); and (iii) ‘taking note if any countries cooperate with ICC investigations of the United States and its allies, and remember[ing] that cooperation when setting US foreign assistance, military assistance and intelligence sharing levels’.

These are serious threats – they would potentially undermine the work of a court that is designed to prosecute the world’s worst crimes. The ICC prosecutor and its judges would be barred entry from the US to attend to vital work of the court.

Some of that work, ironically, is at the behest of the US. For instance, two of the UN Security Council’s referrals to the ICC, one in relation to atrocities committed in Sudan, the other in respect of the crimes committed by Muammar Gaddafi in Libya, were referred with US support.

Also, the meetings of the ICC Assembly of States Parties are held each year at UN headquarters in New York. Those meetings may have to be held elsewhere if the ICC judges and staff are under threat of arrest.

In the case of the potential torture linked to operations in Afghanistan, the ICC has not been acting on its own initiative in investigating. For example, the Center for Constitutional Rights submitted ‘victim’s representations’ to the ICC on behalf of two of their clients, Sharqawi Al Hajj and Guled Hassan Duran, emphasizing the importance of an ICC investigation of US officials for serious crimes arising out of post-9/11 detention and interrogations.

According to the center, both Al Hajj and Duran were detained by the CIA in black sites or 'proxy-detention' by other countries, tormented and tortured.

Although the US is not a party to the ICC Statute, Afghanistan is, and therefore the court has jurisdiction over US nationals who allegedly committed atrocities in Afghanistan. And it should be noted that the investigation includes pursuing any atrocities committed by the Taliban and Afghan security forces during the same period.

So the basis for attacking the work of the ICC based on this is shaky, and Bolton’s threats raise a number of important international law questions going forward.

For one, they may be unlawful retaliatory steps, given that the US has obligations to accord at least some privileges and immunities to judges and other personnel of the ICC under the 1947 UN Headquarters Agreement between the UN and US. Counter-measures might be considered by member states of the ICC, either alone, or collectively.

In this regard, Bolton’s comments about the EU will not go unnoticed: he suggests Europe is a region where ‘the global governance dogma is strong’. The US may yet come to learn just how strong that ‘dogma’ is.

With US abstention from the ICC, the opening remains for Europe and other regions to position themselves at the heart of the international criminal justice regime, thereby – as in response to the US attitude towards climate change – building a network of partnerships with other like-minded nations to compensate for US disengagement.

Further, while the ICC has many critics, and could be improved as an institution, Bolton’s speech may have the effect of galvanizing support for the world’s first permanent international criminal court. That could be a good thing for the court, which is sorely in need of support for its work.

Whatever concerns states may have about the ICC, they may be outweighed by a mutual desire to stand up to perceived bullying by the Trump administration, in favour of the international rule of law.

Bolton’s Attack on the International Criminal Court May Backfire

Dr Max du Plessis SC

2018-09-20-Bolton.jpg

Bulletin updated at 00:00 HKT 10/May/2020

Open government data to public use, and Australia may start to catch up with the world

Pro sport and big data: coaches may be more in favour than athletes

Episode 56 - The Internet of Yahoo! (IoY!) Viral sensations and Marissa Mayer

Maybin brings revamped swing to Giants

Zika related microcephaly may appear after birth, study finds

Diabetes Core Update: COVID-19 – Impact on Youth and their Families, May 2019

Diabetes Core Update – May 2019

Covid-19: NHS bosses told to assess risk to ethnic minority staff who may be at greater risk

Seven days in medicine: 29 Apr to 5 May 2020

Bundesliga to resume on May 16

Concacaf ‘Hex’ may be adjusted

Obesity: raising price of sugary snacks may be more effective than soft drink tax

Reds may play Lorenzen in OF during spring

Covid-19: NHS bosses told to assess risk to ethnic minority staff who may be at greater risk

Often Overlooked Learning Disorder May Affect Millions of Kids

Soccer: Germany's Bundesliga approved to return in mid-May

Soccer: Bundesliga return includes Dortmund on May 16, Bayern Munich, May 17

Peyton Manning trash talks Tom Brady before May 24 golf match

Drug may curb dangerous urges in pedophiles, study says

Air Force sets May 16 launch for X-37B spy plane

University of Minnesota dental school appoints Dr. Keith A. Mays as interim dean

Labor Department says employers with fewer than 50 employees may be exempt from new law

Open Payments data open to review until May 15

May JADA discusses calcium hydroxide overfill risk during root canals

Blood test may effectively spot multiple cancers

Amino acid swap may help wheat tolerate rising heat, scientists say

Unlike 'Jurassic Park,' real raptors may not have hunted in packs

Texas court stays execution of Randall Mays

On This Day, May 9: Freighter collapses Tampa Bay bridge, killing 35

Taylor Swift's Paris concert to air on ABC May 17

Katy Perry to release new song 'Daisies' on May 15

Look: Brian May visits hospital after injuring buttocks while gardening

Michaela Coel's 'I May Destroy You' to premiere June 7 on HBO

Look: Minzy to release 'Lovely' single May 24

Famous birthdays for May 9: Ghostface Killah, Noah Centineo

Psychology Around the Net: May 9, 2020

Why Women May Be More Susceptible to Mood Disorders

Longevity Gene May Protect against a Notorious Alzheimer's Risk Gene

Effective Psychological Therapy May Slow Cellular Aging

Marijuana May Not Lower Your IQ

Forgive and Forget: Maybe Easier Said Than Done

Iraq War Naysayers May Have Hindsight Bias

Best Supporting? Maybe Not.

Among Taxpayers, Inequality May Equal Cheating

Go for It on Fourth Down, Coach? Maybe You Should Ask an Egghead.

Subprime Mortgages and Race: A Bit of Good News May Be Illusory

Mayonnaise

Pork and Pea Pastizzi with Mustard Mayonnnaise

12,000-year-old stones may be oldest example of wheel-like tools

Exposure to Marijuana in the Womb May Increase Risk of Addiction to Opioids Later in Life, Study Finds

Exposure to Marijuana in the Womb May Increase Risk of Addiction to Opioids Later in Life, Study Finds

Salt marshes' capacity to sink carbon may be threatened by nitrogen pollution

Maya Kaimal Naan Chips

Mechanic, Express Oil, Notes That Oil May Last Longer Than 3K Miles, But Oil Filter May Not

"I always hated that word—marketing—and I hate it now. Because for me, and this may sound simplistic,..."

More from Musalem: Data since prior meeting suggests economy may be materially stronger

Why The Mandalorian Season 4 May Never Happen

Demings says Orange County may sue election supervisor over $4 million giveaway

Google's Gemini Live may let you talk to it about your uploaded files

Metsola asegura que la Eurocámara está dispuesta a ayudar a Valencia "como sea", incluyendo "mayor flexibilidad para la asistencia financiera"

La tributación de los parados mayores de 25 años a cargo de sus padres

Marco Rubio, el mayor peligro para Obama

Vampire Weekend se hacen mayores

Subscribe To Our Newsletter