Latest ecad news

ecad

Four Charts Explaining Latin America’s Decade of Development-less Growth

By webfeeds.brookings.edu
Published On :: Fri, 05 Dec 2014 15:12:00 -0500

Editor’s Note: In the report “Think Tank 20: Growth, Convergence and Income Distribution: The Road from the Brisbane G-20 Summit” experts from Brookings and around the world address interrelated debates about growth, convergence and income distribution, three key elements that are likely to shape policy debates beyond the ninth G-20 summit that was held on November 15-16 in Brisbane, Australia. The content of this blog is based on the chapter on Latin America. Read the full brief on Latin America's growth trends here.

A figure says a thousand words. And, looking at Figure 1, which shows the population-weighted average income per capita in emerging economies relative to the U.S., there could be no doubt in anybody’s mind that since the late 1990s something rather extraordinary happened—a phenomenon with no antecedents in the post-WWII period—that propelled emerging economies into an exponential process of convergence.

Needless to say, this phenomenon had enormous consequences for the welfare of millions of citizens in emerging economies. It lifted more than 500 million people out from poverty and extreme poverty, and gave rise to the so-called emerging middle class that grew at a rate of 150 million per year.

So, it seems that something rather extraordinary happened in emerging economies. Or did it? Let’s look again. When China and India are removed from the emerging markets sample, Figure 1 becomes Figure 2a.

In Figure 2a, one can still discern a period of convergence starting in the late 1990s. But convergence here was not nearly as strong—relative income is still far below its previous heights—and it occurred after a period of divergence that started in the mid-1970s after the first oil shock, in the early 1980s with the debt crisis, and in the late 1980s with post-Berlin Wall meltdown in Eastern European economies.

This pattern is actually characteristic of every emerging region including Latin America (see Figure 2b). Only Asia differs markedly from this pattern—with China and India displaying exponential convergence since the late 1990s, while the rest of emerging Asia experienced a sustained but much slower convergence since the mid-1960s.

From a Latin American perspective, the relevant question we need to ask is whether the recent bout of convergence that started in 2004 after a quarter of a century of relative income decline is a break with the past or just a short-lived phenomenon?

In order to address this question from a Latin American perspective, we study the arithmetic of convergence (i.e., whether mechanical projections are consistent with the convergence hypothesis) and the economics of convergence (i.e., whether income convergence was associated with a comparable convergence in the drivers of growth).

According to our definition of convergence,[1] since 1950, growth-convergence-development miracles represent a tiny fraction of emerging countries. Only five countries managed to achieve this: Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong and Singapore. In other words, convergence towards income per capita levels of rich countries is an extremely rare event.

But where does Latin America stand? Based on growth projections for the period 2014-2018, not a single Latin American country will converge to two-thirds of U.S. income per capita in two generations. Unfortunately, the arithmetic does not seem to be on the side of the region.

What about the economics? To answer this question, we analyze whether Latin America’s process of income convergence in the last decade was also associated with a similar convergence in the key drivers of growth: trade integration, physical and technological infrastructure, human capital, innovation, and the quality of public services. Figure 3 illustrates the results.

In contrast to relative income, during the last decade, LAC-7 [2] countries failed to converge towards advanced country levels in every growth driver. The overall index of growth drivers—the simple average of the five sub-indexes—remained unchanged in the last decade relative to the equivalent index for advanced economies. By and large, the latter holds true for every LAC-7 country with exceptions like Colombia (the only country that improved in every single growth driver in the last decade) and Chile (the country in the region where the levels of growth drivers are closer to those of advanced economies).

Latin America had a decade of uninterrupted high growth rates—with the sole exception of 2009 in the aftermath of the Lehman crisis—that put an end to a quarter of a century of relative decline in income per capita levels vis-à-vis advanced economies. However, high growth and income convergence were largely the result of an unusually favorable external environment, rather than the result of convergence to advanced-country levels in the key drivers of growth. Fundamentally, the last was a decade of “development-less growth” in Latin America.

With the extremely favorable external conditions already behind us, the region is expected to grow at mediocre rates of around 2 percent in per capita terms for the foreseeable future. With this level of growth, the dream of convergence and development is unlikely to be realized any time soon.

To avoid such a fate the region must make a renewed effort of economic transformation. Although the challenges ahead appear to be huge, there is plenty of room for optimism. First, Latin America has built a sound platform to launch a process of development. Democracy has by-and-large consolidated across the region, and an entire generation has now grown up to see an election as the only legitimate way to select national leaders. Moreover, it is for the most part a relatively stable region with no armed conflicts and few insurgency movements threatening the authority of the state. Second, a sizeable group of major countries in Latin America have a long track record of sound macroeconomic performance by now. Third, the region could be just steps away from major economic integration. Most Latin American countries in the Pacific Coast have bilateral free trade agreements with their North American neighbors (11 countries with the U.S. and seven countries with Canada). Were these countries to harmonize current bilateral trade agreements among themselves—in the way Pacific Alliance members have been doing—a huge economic space would be born: a Trans-American Partnership that would comprise 620 million consumers, and have a combined GDP of more than $22 trillion (larger than the EU’s, and more than double that of China). Were such a partnership on the Pacific side of the Americas to gain traction, it could eventually be extended to Atlantic partners, in particular Brazil and other Mercosur countries.

In the last quarter of a century democracy, sound macroeconomic management and an outward-looking development strategy made substantial strides in the region. If these conquests are consolidated and the same kind of progress is achieved in key development drivers in the next 25 years, many countries in the region could be on the road to convergence.

[1] We define convergence as a process whereby a country’s income per capita starts at or below one-third of U.S. income per capita at any point in time since 1950, and rises to or above two-thirds of U.S. income per capita.

[2] LAC-7 is the simple average of Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Mexico, Peru and Venezuela, which account for 93 percent of Latin America’s GDP.

Authors

Ernesto Talvi
Santiago García da Rosa
Rafael Guntin
Rafael Xavier
Federico Ganz
Mercedes Cejas
Julia Ruiz Pozuelo

Four Charts Explaining Latin America’s Decade of Development-less Growth

Authors

A once-in-a-century pandemic collides with a once-in-a-decade census

A once-in-a-century pandemic collides with a once-in-a-decade census

The Islamic Republic of Iran four decades on: The 2017/18 protests amid a triple crisis

A once-in-a-century pandemic collides with a once-in-a-decade census

A once-in-a-century pandemic collides with a once-in-a-decade census

A once-in-a-century pandemic collides with a once-in-a-decade census

A Climate Agreement for the Decades

Yikes! California's extreme drought could last "a decade or more", 2014 driest year in a century

Bumble bees could vanish forever within a few decades

Toxic Algae Bloom in Lake Erie Worst in Decades

6 mega-trends that marked the past decade

This was the decade of the bicycle. What's next?

Make room for the e-bikes, the top-selling electric vehicles for the next decade

Cutting U.S. meat consumption by half would reduce dietary emissions by 35% within decade

Top 10 tiny homes of the decade

Three tweets that changed my decade

How Ghent got rid of cars and transformed the city in a decade

Seattle Chocolates: Decadent flavors from ethically-sourced ingredients, now feeding the hungry

Air quality hasn't been this good in decades. How can we keep it this way?

We call this decade 'the age of delivery': Domino's CEO

Stocks just posted their best month in decades, yet most of Wall Street hates this rally

Analyst looking to build portfolios that will 'last the next decade'

Pandemic disarmament: Why France was ready for Covid-19 a decade too soon

How Florian Schneider and Kraftwerk influenced five decades of music

Rahul Bose: Need ground campaign over decades for gender justice

Telly tattle: Mohsin Khan completes a decade in the industry, shares his thoughts

Voice of hope

Press Release: Almost 75 Crore people in South Asia affected by climate hazards in last decade

Top 3 Travel Destinations of Decade: Bangkok, London, Paris

Kidney Replacement Therapy Rates Have Remained Higher in Men Vs. Women for Decades: Study

Abortion Authorized in Chile After a Decade

Increasing Cases of Euthanasia in Belgium Over a Decade

First New HIV Strain Discovered in Almost Two Decades

Decades-old Ban on Gay Men Donating Blood Finally Removed by the FDA

Health spending in Europe falls for the first time in decades

The Mexican health care system has made great progress during the last decade – but the remaining challenges are daunting

Five decades at the heart of financial modernisation: The OECD and its Committee on Financial Markets

Global growth to slow as wage inequality rises over coming decades, says OECD

Labour share developments over the past two decades: The role of technological progress, globalisation and "winner-takes-most" dynamics

OECD and FAO expect stronger agricultural production, lower prices over coming decade - Rising incomes in developing world spurring demand for food, dietary changes

Five decades, 25 films — Nigel Andrews’ favourites

Latin America faces a second ‘lost decade’

Saudi central bank’s foreign assets fall by most in two decades

Design decade

Design decade

The trends that shaped a decade of domestic life

Sasol plans South Africa’s biggest rights issue in decades

Wall Street has best day in decade as stimulus nears

Liberty Global and Telefónica dial up changes in ‘deal of decade’

Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi make the cut but who else does? Europe's best XI of the decade

La decadencia en catalán

CAA has not undergone formal audit for past decade, NA panel told

Decades after spotting a mysterious creature in the deep, researchers announce a new species

Coppin State University to Highlight Decades-Long Partnership with Fischer Identity at MEEC

Google Spent a Decade Researching What Makes a Great Boss. They Came Up With These 10 Things

Amsterdam, The Netherlands - some six decades after B-Day..

Strange Fitness Fads This Decade

9 Podcasts That Have Shaped The Decade

Spotify Wrapped extends to add your favorite music from the decade, plus podcaster metrics

Gravity Falls and a Decade Long Education in (Bill) Ciphering

Kenya: Steeplechase World Record Holder Chepkoech Reminisces On Decade Track Career

Kenya: Health Ministry Reports 83% Drop in New HIV Infection in a Decade

AMD Will Need Another Decade To Try To Pass Nvidia - note the gaming revenue trends

Liberación de Pecado

Bristol Academy beat Barcelona - a decade on

Subscribe To Our Newsletter