bust Jointly Robust Prior for Gaussian Stochastic Process in Emulation, Calibration and Variable Selection By projecteuclid.org Published On :: Tue, 11 Jun 2019 04:00 EDT Mengyang Gu. Source: Bayesian Analysis, Volume 14, Number 3, 877--905.Abstract: Gaussian stochastic process (GaSP) has been widely used in two fundamental problems in uncertainty quantification, namely the emulation and calibration of mathematical models. Some objective priors, such as the reference prior, are studied in the context of emulating (approximating) computationally expensive mathematical models. In this work, we introduce a new class of priors, called the jointly robust prior, for both the emulation and calibration. This prior is designed to maintain various advantages from the reference prior. In emulation, the jointly robust prior has an appropriate tail decay rate as the reference prior, and is computationally simpler than the reference prior in parameter estimation. Moreover, the marginal posterior mode estimation with the jointly robust prior can separate the influential and inert inputs in mathematical models, while the reference prior does not have this property. We establish the posterior propriety for a large class of priors in calibration, including the reference prior and jointly robust prior in general scenarios, but the jointly robust prior is preferred because the calibrated mathematical model typically predicts the reality well. The jointly robust prior is used as the default prior in two new R packages, called “RobustGaSP” and “RobustCalibration”, available on CRAN for emulation and calibration, respectively. Full Article
bust Man convicted of double murder in Fort Frances charged in $2.2M Winnipeg drug bust By www.cbc.ca Published On :: Wed, 6 May 2020 11:42:58 EDT Two men are charged in connection with an illegal drug distribution operation after Winnipeg police seized more than $2.2 million worth of methamphetamine, cocaine and ecstasy. Full Article News/Canada/Manitoba
bust Cape Breton businesses busting boredom with DIY kits By www.cbc.ca Published On :: Sat, 9 May 2020 05:00:00 EDT Businesses in Cape Breton are helping customers get creative with DIY take-home kits to make everything from mermaid-themed terrariums to bubble tea. Full Article News/Canada/Nova Scotia
bust Busting the Zip Code Curse with Blended Learning By feedproxy.google.com Published On :: Mon, 07 Mar 2016 00:00:00 +0000 Online learning holds great potential to transform rural education by ensuring that every student has access to great instruction. Full Article Blended+Learning
bust Robust Delaware watermelon season begins By news.delaware.gov Published On :: Mon, 29 Jul 2013 14:03:17 +0000 A strong Delaware watermelon season is now under way, with First State melons now reaching customers in grocery stores and markets along the East Coast, from New England to Florida. This season is featuring good yields and excellent quality for Delaware watermelon growers, said Secretary of Agriculture Ed Kee. The First State produces both seeded and seedless watermelon. Full Article Department of Agriculture News
bust America facing debt ‘conundrum’ – former Fed insider tells Boom Bust By www.rt.com Published On :: Fri, 08 May 2020 10:08:25 +0000 The US 10-year Treasury bond yield fell 0.7 percent in response to the latest report of jobless claims. That comes a week after the Treasury said it would borrow a record $2.99 trillion this quarter, and launch a 20-year bond. Read Full Article at RT.com Full Article
bust The best college sports prospects we ever saw: The Answer, Buster Posey and Andrew Luck By www.espn.com Published On :: Fri, 8 May 2020 08:57:13 EST ESPN's colleges writers and reporters reflect on the phenoms they had a chance to cover before they were famous. Full Article
bust Police Bust Man For Selling 1 Million Netflix, Spotify Passwords By packetstormsecurity.com Published On :: Wed, 13 Mar 2019 14:20:00 GMT Full Article headline government australia cybercrime data loss fraud password
bust Mythbusters RFID Episode Axed After Pressure From Credit Card Firms By packetstormsecurity.com Published On :: Wed, 03 Sep 2008 00:43:56 GMT Full Article bank rfid
bust Lulzbuster 1.0.0 By packetstormsecurity.com Published On :: Fri, 24 Jan 2020 15:44:44 GMT Lulzbuster is a very fast and smart web directory and file enumeration tool written in C. Full Article
bust Lulzbuster 1.1.0 By packetstormsecurity.com Published On :: Fri, 31 Jan 2020 15:42:11 GMT Lulzbuster is a very fast and smart web directory and file enumeration tool written in C. Full Article
bust Lulzbuster 1.2.0 By packetstormsecurity.com Published On :: Tue, 18 Feb 2020 10:11:11 GMT Lulzbuster is a very fast and smart web directory and file enumeration tool written in C. Full Article
bust Lulzbuster 1.3.2 By packetstormsecurity.com Published On :: Tue, 17 Mar 2020 13:18:24 GMT Lulzbuster is a very fast and smart web directory and file enumeration tool written in C. Full Article
bust Hackers Busted In Online Poker Cheats By packetstormsecurity.com Published On :: Mon, 28 Jun 2010 11:26:49 GMT Full Article hacker gamble
bust China To Crack Down On Censor-Busting Services By packetstormsecurity.com Published On :: Mon, 23 Jan 2017 16:16:08 GMT Full Article headline government china censorship
bust Busting the Myth of “Job-Killing EPA Regulations” By feedproxy.google.com Published On :: 2014-12-23T13:28:00Z Earlier this month, when EPA proposed a new health-protective air quality standard for the pollutants that form “ozone,” some critics predictably pounced on it as another example of a long string of “job-killing EPA regulations.” Yet last week, we learned that the U.S. economy created about 320,000 new jobs in November, and average wages are starting to rise as the labor market tightens. Full Article Energy Efficiency Hydropower Baseload Storage Energy Efficiency Bioenergy Policy Wind Power Opinion & Commentary Solar Geothermal
bust Man involved in Hawke's Bay $2.5 million meth bust gets prison sentence dropped By www.nzherald.co.nz Published On :: Sat, 09 May 2020 11:27:05 +1200 A man involved in a $2.5 million meth bust in Hawke's Bay has had his three and a half year prison sentence dropped to 12 months of home detention.Uriah Whetu Monty Wirihana received a prison sentence of three years and seven months... Full Article
bust Hong Kong police sergeant may have stolen 25kg in crystal meth from scene of record-breaking bust he supervised, sources say By www.scmp.com Published On :: Fri, 08 May 2020 20:42:55 +0800 A Hong Kong police officer arrested in connection with the seizure of 25kg of drugs worth HK$12 million is believed to have orchestrated its theft from the scene of a bust he was personally in charge of last week, according to police sources.If true, it would mean the announced record seizure of 296kg of Ice, a form of methamphetamine, actually involved 321kg.Sources said the station sergeant, who was arrested along with a constable in connection with the missing drugs, was in charge of the… Full Article
bust News24.co.ke | Kisii County teacher busted for impersonating KCSE pupils By www.news24.co.ke Published On :: Tue, 08 Nov 2016 15:01:49 +0200 A high school teacher in Kisii County was arrested on Tuesday for impersonating a 20-year old girl during a KCSE exam. Full Article
bust Hrithik Roshan in talks with directors for blockbuster future projects By feedproxy.google.com Published On :: Wed, 06 May 2020 07:41:10 +0500 Hrithik Roshan had an extraordinary 2019, having made two hit movies in a row Full Article
bust Lebanon rooftops bustle as virus shifts life upstairs By www.dailystar.com.lb Published On :: 2020-05-09T15:02:00.0000000 Usually the kingdom of water tanks and satellite dishes, Lebanon's rooftops have recently been graced by unlikely scenes of locked-down residents fleeing their flats. Full Article Lebanon News
bust Your Money: Get aid or go bust? Small businesses face dilemma By feeds.reuters.com Published On :: Mon, 13 Apr 2020 16:03:26 -0400 Sara Pauly is not one of those small business owners scrambling to fill out paperwork for part of the more than $350 billion in government aid available through the Paycheck Protection Program or the... Full Article PersonalFinance
bust As Trump returns to the road, some Democrats want to bust Biden out of his basement By feeds.reuters.com Published On :: Sat, 09 May 2020 07:32:43 -0400 While President Donald Trump traveled to the battleground state of Arizona this week, his Democratic opponent for the White House, Joe Biden, campaigned from his basement as he has done throughout the coronavirus pandemic. Full Article topNews
bust Robustness in an Ultrasensitive Motor By mbio.asm.org Published On :: 2020-03-03T01:30:27-08:00 ABSTRACT In Escherichia coli, the chemotaxis response regulator CheY-P binds to FliM, a component of the switch complex at the base of the bacterial flagellar motor, to modulate the direction of motor rotation. The bacterial flagellar motor is ultrasensitive to the concentration of unbound CheY-P in the cytoplasm. CheY-P binds to FliM molecules both in the cytoplasm and on the motor. As the concentration of FliM unavoidably varies from cell to cell, leading to a variation of unbound CheY-P concentration in the cytoplasm, this raises the question whether the flagellar motor is robust against this variation, that is, whether the rotational bias of the motor is more or less constant as the concentration of FliM varies. Here, we showed that the motor is robust against variations of the concentration of FliM. We identified adaptive remodeling of the motor as the mechanism for this robustness. As the level of FliM molecules changes, resulting in different amounts of the unbound CheY-P molecules, the motor adaptively changes the composition of its switch complex to compensate for this effect. IMPORTANCE The bacterial flagellar motor is an ultrasensitive motor. Its output, the probability of the motor turning clockwise, depends sensitively on the occupancy of the protein FliM (a component on the switch complex of the motor) by the input CheY-P molecules. With a limited cellular pool of CheY-P molecules, cell-to-cell variation of the FliM level would lead to large unwanted variation of the motor output if not compensated. Here, we showed that the motor output is robust against the variation of FliM level and identified the adaptive remodeling of the motor switch complex as the mechanism for this robustness. Full Article
bust Avoiding Drug Resistance by Substrate Envelope-Guided Design: Toward Potent and Robust HCV NS3/4A Protease Inhibitors By mbio.asm.org Published On :: 2020-03-31T01:30:58-07:00 ABSTRACT Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infects millions of people worldwide, causing chronic liver disease that can lead to cirrhosis, hepatocellular carcinoma, and liver transplant. In the last several years, the advent of direct-acting antivirals, including NS3/4A protease inhibitors (PIs), has remarkably improved treatment outcomes of HCV-infected patients. However, selection of resistance-associated substitutions and polymorphisms among genotypes can lead to drug resistance and in some cases treatment failure. A proactive strategy to combat resistance is to constrain PIs within evolutionarily conserved regions in the protease active site. Designing PIs using the substrate envelope is a rational strategy to decrease the susceptibility to resistance by using the constraints of substrate recognition. We successfully designed two series of HCV NS3/4A PIs to leverage unexploited areas in the substrate envelope to improve potency, specifically against resistance-associated substitutions at D168. Our design strategy achieved better resistance profiles over both the FDA-approved NS3/4A PI grazoprevir and the parent compound against the clinically relevant D168A substitution. Crystallographic structural analysis and inhibition assays confirmed that optimally filling the substrate envelope is critical to improve inhibitor potency while avoiding resistance. Specifically, inhibitors that enhanced hydrophobic packing in the S4 pocket and avoided an energetically frustrated pocket performed the best. Thus, the HCV substrate envelope proved to be a powerful tool to design robust PIs, offering a strategy that can be translated to other targets for rational design of inhibitors with improved potency and resistance profiles. IMPORTANCE Despite significant progress, hepatitis C virus (HCV) continues to be a major health problem with millions of people infected worldwide and thousands dying annually due to resulting complications. Recent antiviral combinations can achieve >95% cure, but late diagnosis, low access to treatment, and treatment failure due to drug resistance continue to be roadblocks against eradication of the virus. We report the rational design of two series of HCV NS3/4A protease inhibitors with improved resistance profiles by exploiting evolutionarily constrained regions of the active site using the substrate envelope model. Optimally filling the S4 pocket is critical to avoid resistance and improve potency. Our results provide drug design strategies to avoid resistance that are applicable to other quickly evolving viral drug targets. Full Article
bust A Simple, Cost-Effective, and Robust Method for rRNA Depletion in RNA-Sequencing Studies By mbio.asm.org Published On :: 2020-04-21T01:31:26-07:00 ABSTRACT The profiling of gene expression by RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) has enabled powerful studies of global transcriptional patterns in all organisms, including bacteria. Because the vast majority of RNA in bacteria is rRNA, it is standard practice to deplete the rRNA from a total RNA sample such that the reads in an RNA-seq experiment derive predominantly from mRNA. One of the most commonly used commercial kits for rRNA depletion, the Ribo-Zero kit from Illumina, was recently discontinued abruptly and for an extended period of time. Here, we report the development of a simple, cost-effective, and robust method for depleting rRNA that can be easily implemented by any lab or facility. We first developed an algorithm for designing biotinylated oligonucleotides that will hybridize tightly and specifically to the 23S, 16S, and 5S rRNAs from any species of interest. Precipitation of these oligonucleotides bound to rRNA by magnetic streptavidin-coated beads then depletes rRNA from a complex, total RNA sample such that ~75 to 80% of reads in a typical RNA-seq experiment derive from mRNA. Importantly, we demonstrate a high correlation of RNA abundance or fold change measurements in RNA-seq experiments between our method and the Ribo-Zero kit. Complete details on the methodology are provided, including open-source software for designing oligonucleotides optimized for any bacterial species or community of interest. IMPORTANCE The ability to examine global patterns of gene expression in microbes through RNA sequencing has fundamentally transformed microbiology. However, RNA-seq depends critically on the removal of rRNA from total RNA samples. Otherwise, rRNA would comprise upward of 90% of the reads in a typical RNA-seq experiment, limiting the reads coming from mRNA or requiring high total read depth. A commonly used kit for rRNA subtraction from Illumina was recently unavailable for an extended period of time, disrupting routine rRNA depletion. Here, we report the development of a "do-it-yourself" kit for rapid, cost-effective, and robust depletion of rRNA from total RNA. We present an algorithm for designing biotinylated oligonucleotides that will hybridize to the rRNAs from a target set of species. We then demonstrate that the designed oligonucleotides enable sufficient rRNA depletion to produce RNA-seq data with 75 to 80% of reads coming from mRNA. The methodology presented should enable RNA-seq studies on any species or metagenomic sample of interest. Full Article
bust Bioprocess: Robustness with Respect to Mycoplasma Species By journal.pda.org Published On :: 2020-04-09T09:40:03-07:00 Capture bioprocessing unit operations were previously shown to clear or kill several log10 of a model mycoplasma Acholeplasma laidlawii in lab-scale spike/removal studies. Here, we confirm this observation with two additional mollicute species relevant to biotechnology products for human use: Mycoplasma orale and Mycoplasma arginini. Clearance of M. orale and M. arginini from protein A column purification was similar to that seen with A. laidlawii, though some between cycle carryover was evident, especially for M. orale. However, on-resin growth studies for all three species revealed that residual mycoplasma in a column slowly die off over time rather than expanding further. Solvent/detergent exposure completely inactivated M. arginini though detectable levels of M. orale remained. A small-scale model of a commercial low-pH hold step did inactivate live M. orale, but this inactivation required a lower pH set point and occurred with slower kinetics than previously seen with A. laidlawii. Additionally, ultraviolet-C irradiation was shown to be effective for A. laidlawii and M. orale inactivation whereas virus-retentive filters for upstream and downstream processes, as expected, cleared A. laidlawii. These data argue that M. orale and M. arginini overall would be largely cleared by early bioprocessing steps as shown previously for A. laidlawii, and that barrier technologies can effectively reduce the risk from media components. For some unit operations, M. orale and M. arginini may be hardier, and require more stringent processing or equipment cleaning conditions to assure effective mycoplasma reduction. By exploring how some of the failure modes in commercial antibody manufacturing processes can still eliminate mycoplasma burden, we demonstrate that required best practices assure biotechnology products will be safe for patients. Full Article
bust Gladiator at 20: how Ridley Scott's epic rejuvenated the historical blockbuster By www.theguardian.com Published On :: 2020-05-04T08:00:15Z The Oscar-winning sword-and-sandals Russell Crowe vehicle refreshed old cliches, before ushering in a spate of copycats “Joey, do you like movies about gladiators?” the creepy pilot asks the small boy in Airplane!. To younger audiences, the joke no longer makes any sense. In Airplane!’s day, sword-and-sandals movies had become an outdated, unwittingly homoerotic joke. But then came Gladiator, and the joke was on us. Released 20 years ago this month, Ridley Scott’s Roman epic gave the old cliches a new lease of life. It was all here: Colosseum action! Rippling man-flesh! Tigers! But Gladiator had its cheesecake and ate it. It served up crowd-pleasing spectacle and airline-ad visuals but also solemn, Oscar-worthy drama (and, in retrospect, a fair degree of camp). Related: The Guide: Staying In – sign up for our home entertainment tips Continue reading... Full Article Gladiator Film Culture
bust As Trump returns to the road, some Democrats want to bust Biden out of his basement By feeds.reuters.com Published On :: Sat, 09 May 2020 07:32:43 -0400 While President Donald Trump traveled to the battleground state of Arizona this week, his Democratic opponent for the White House, Joe Biden, campaigned from his basement as he has done throughout the coronavirus pandemic. Full Article domesticNews
bust As Trump returns to the road, some Democrats want to bust Biden out of his basement By feeds.reuters.com Published On :: Sat, 09 May 2020 07:32:43 -0400 While President Donald Trump traveled to the battleground state of Arizona this week, his Democratic opponent for the White House, Joe Biden, campaigned from his basement as he has done throughout the coronavirus pandemic. Full Article politicsNews
bust All these clowns do is LIE! Crap media (and Jimmy Kimmel) BUSTED for pushing fake story about Mike Pence delivering empty PPE boxes By twitchy.com Published On :: Fri, 08 May 2020 12:18:12 Z Full Article <![CDATA[Jimmy Kimmel]]> <![CDATA[media]]> <![CDATA[Mike Pence]]> <![CDATA[PPE]]>
bust 'Are you kidding me?' Jimmy Kimmel offers the biggest non-apology in the history of non-apologies after getting busted peddling BS about Pence By twitchy.com Published On :: Fri, 08 May 2020 14:25:53 Z Full Article <![CDATA[Jimmy Kimmel]]> <![CDATA[Mike Pence]]>
bust 'Friday the 13th' at 40: How this horror classic cemented the blockbuster slasher By uk.movies.yahoo.com Published On :: Fri, 08 May 2020 11:21:05 GMT Sean S. Cunningham's slasher 'Friday the 13th' is celebrating its 40th anniversary this week. Its effect on the horror genre defined the 1980s. Full Article
bust Chris Hemsworth hopes Marvel blockbusters will bring audiences to reopened cinemas By www.film-news.co.uk Published On :: Sat, 09 May 2020 09:15:00 +0100 The Thor star was thankful to finally be on a well-deserved break from his hectic schedule. Full Article
bust Apartment owners fear for 'suicidal' neighbours as combustible cladding crisis takes its toll By www.abc.net.au Published On :: Wed, 23 Oct 2019 17:28:00 +1100 Owners of apartments affected by the combustible cladding crisis in Victoria tell researchers of the emotional and financial toll it has taken on them and their neighbours. Full Article ABC Radio Sydney sydney melbourne Business Economics and Finance:Industry:Building and Construction Business Economics and Finance:Industry:Housing Business Economics and Finance:Regulation:All Government and Politics:States and Territories:All Australia:All:All Australia:NSW:Sydney 2000 Australia:VIC:Melbourne 3000
bust Virus turns New York from bustling metropolis to open-air museum By www.brisbanetimes.com.au Published On :: Sat, 28 Mar 2020 04:30:02 GMT In the days before the virus, strolling down Broadway felt like swimming through a sea of people. Now it feels like wandering around a forsaken movie set. Full Article
bust No hustle. No bustle. Emptiness and stillness fill the streets By www.smh.com.au Published On :: Fri, 17 Apr 2020 10:55:00 GMT As the Great Lockdown continues our cities are looking strangely familiar yet eerily different. Full Article
bust The Great Lockdown is a sledgehammer busting dreams that won't bounce back By www.smh.com.au Published On :: Sat, 18 Apr 2020 11:02:01 GMT It’s like a giant version of the Kings Cross lockout. Full Article
bust No hustle. No bustle. Emptiness and stillness fill the streets By www.brisbanetimes.com.au Published On :: Fri, 17 Apr 2020 10:55:00 GMT As the Great Lockdown continues our cities are looking strangely familiar yet eerily different. Full Article
bust The Great Lockdown is a sledgehammer busting dreams that won't bounce back By www.brisbanetimes.com.au Published On :: Sat, 18 Apr 2020 11:02:01 GMT It’s like a giant version of the Kings Cross lockout. Full Article
bust Ghostbusters faces ban in China By www.smh.com.au Published On :: Wed, 13 Jul 2016 21:56:06 GMT It may be poised to become a blockbuster hit around the world, but audiences in China are likely to miss out on seeing the film. Full Article
bust No hustle. No bustle. Emptiness and stillness fill the streets By www.theage.com.au Published On :: Fri, 17 Apr 2020 10:55:00 GMT As the Great Lockdown continues our cities are looking strangely familiar yet eerily different. Full Article
bust The Great Lockdown is a sledgehammer busting dreams that won't bounce back By www.theage.com.au Published On :: Sat, 18 Apr 2020 11:02:01 GMT It’s like a giant version of the Kings Cross lockout. Full Article
bust Peter V'landys's hyper-aggressive approach to restarting the NRL could end in boom or bust By www.abc.net.au Published On :: Tue, 28 Apr 2020 04:40:19 +1000 Flattering comparisons with other leading sports officials have also helped elevate the ARL chairman's current status as the can-do man of Australian sport, but as Richard Hinds asks, is he about to make a huge mistake? Full Article NRL Rugby League Sport COVID-19 Diseases and Disorders Health
bust Novel ADC continues on path to blockbuster status By www.thepharmaletter.com Published On :: Thu, 07 May 2020 15:39:00 +0100 Tokyo’s Daiichi Sankyo has submitted a supplemental New Drug Application (sNDA) for trastuzumab deruxtecan… Full Article Asia Pacific/AstraZeneca/Biotechnology/Daiichi Sankyo/Enhertu/Focus On/Japan/Oncology/Regulation/Research/trastuzumab deruxtecan/UK
bust Justice Department Reaches Settlement with Blockbuster Inc. Under the Americans with Disabilities Act By www.justice.gov Published On :: Mon, 19 Jul 2010 15:48:17 EDT The Justice Department today announced a settlement agreement under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) with Blockbuster Inc. to ensure equal access to its stores nationwide for individuals with disabilities who use service animals. Full Article OPA Press Releases
bust FDA approval delayed for Sanofi Genzyme’s next blockbuster By www.bizjournals.com Published On :: Fri, 28 Oct 2016 11:11:53 +0000 Editor's note: This story was originally published Friday morning, and has been updated to reflect the FDA's decision regarding the drug later that day. A U.S. approval decision for a major drug planned to be marketed by Cambridge-based Sanofi Genzyme that had been expected last Friday has been delayed due to “deficiencies” found during a manufacturing site inspection in France. In its third quarter report, released Friday morning, French drugmaker Sanofi (NYSE: SNY) disclosed that “manufacturing… Full Article
bust Yokogawa Releases AI-enabled Versions of SMARTDAC+ Paperless Recorders and Data Logging Software, and Environmentally Robust AI-enabled e-RT3 Plus Edge Computing Platform for Industry Applications By www.yokogawa.com Published On :: 2020-04-07T16:00:00+09:00 Yokogawa Electric Corporation (TOKYO: 6841) announces the release of artificial intelligence (AI)-enabled versions of the GX series panel-mount type paperless recorders, GP series portable paperless recorders, and GA10 data logging software, which are components of the highly operable and expandable SMARTDAC+data acquisition and control system. This new AI functionality includes the future pen, a function developed by Yokogawa that enables the drawing of predicted waveforms. Yokogawa is also releasing a new CPU module for the e-RT3 Plus edge computing platform that is environmentally robust and Python compatible. The GX/GP and e-RT3 release is set for April 8, and the GA10 software will be released on May 13. The SMARTDAC+ system is a product in the OpreX Data Acquisition family, and the e-RT3 Plus is part of the OpreX Control Devices family. Full Article
bust What Senators Need to Know about Filibuster Reform By webfeeds.brookings.edu Published On :: Thu, 02 Dec 2010 00:00:00 -0500 Dear Members of the Senate,As you know, the Senate has debated the merits of the filibuster and related procedural rules for over two centuries. Recently, several senators who are advocating changes to Senate Rule XXII have renewed this discussion. We write this letter today to clarify some of the common historical and constitutional misperceptions about the filibuster and Rule XXII that all too often surface during debates about Senate rules. First, many argue that senators have a constitutional right to extended debate. However, there is no explicit constitutional right to filibuster.[1] In fact, there is ample evidence that the framers preferred majority rather than supermajority voting rules. The framers knew full well the difficulties posed by supermajority rules, given their experiences in the Confederation Congress under the Articles of Confederation (which required a supermajority vote to pass measures on the most important matters). A common result was stalemate; legislators frequently found themselves unable to muster support from a supermajority of the states for essential matters of governing. In the Constitution, the framers specified that supermajority votes would be necessary in seven, extraordinary situations -which they specifically listed (including overriding a presidential veto, expelling a member of the Senate, and ratifying a treaty). These, of course, are all voting requirements for passing measures, rather than rules for bringing debate to a close. Second, although historical lore says that the filibuster was part of the original design of the Senate, there is no empirical basis for that view. There is no question that the framers intended the Senate to be a deliberative body. But they sought to achieve that goal through structural features of the chamber intended to facilitate deliberation -such as the Senate's smaller size, longer and staggered terms, and older members. There is no historical evidence that the framers anticipated that the Senate would adopt rules allowing for a filibuster. In fact, the first House and the first Senate had nearly identical rule books, both of which included a motion to move the previous question. The House converted that rule into a simple majority cloture rule early in its history. The Senate did not. What happened to the Senate's previous question motion? In 1805, as presiding officer of the Senate, Vice President Aaron Burr recommended a pruning of the Senate's rules. He singled out the previous question motion as unnecessary (keeping in mind that the rule had not yet routinely been used in either chamber as a simple majority cloture motion). When senators met in 1806 to re-codify the rules, they deleted the previous question motion from the Senate rulebook. Senators did so not because they sought to create the opportunity to filibuster; they abandoned the motion as a matter of procedural housekeeping. Deletion of the motion took away one of the possible avenues for cutting off debate by majority vote, but did not constitute a deliberate choice to allow obstruction. The first documented filibusters did not occur until the 1830s, and for the next century they were rare (but often effective) occurrences in a chamber in which majorities generally reigned. Finally, the adoption of Rule XXII in 1917 did not reflect a broad-based Senate preference for a supermajority cloture rule. At that time, a substantial portion of the majority party favored a simple majority rule. But many minority party members preferred a supermajority cloture rule, while others preferred no cloture rule at all. A bargain was struck: Opponents of reform promised not to block the rule change and proponents of reform promised not to push for a simple majority cloture rule. The two-thirds threshold, in other words, was the product of bargaining and compromise with the minority. As has been typical of the Senate's past episodes of procedural change, pragmatic politics largely shaped reform of the Senate's rules. We hope this historical perspective on the origins of the filibuster and Rule XXII will be helpful to you as matters of reform are raised and debated. Please do not hesitate to contact us if we can provide additional clarification. Very truly yours, Sarah Binder Senior Fellow, Governance Studies, The Brookings Institution Professor of Political Science, George Washington University Gregory Koger Associate Professor of Political Science, University of Miami Thomas E. Mann W. Averell Harriman Chair & Senior Fellow, Governance Studies, The Brookings Institution Norman Ornstein Resident Scholar, American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research Eric Schickler Jeffrey & Ashley McDermott Endowed Chair & Professor of Political Science, University of California, Berkeley Barbara Sinclair Marvin Hoffenberg Professor of American Politics Emerita, University of California, Los Angeles Steven S. Smith Kate M. Gregg Distinguished Professor of Social Sciences & Professor of Political Science, Washington University Gregory J. Wawro Deputy Chair & Associate Professor of Political Science, Columbia University [1] In Article I, Section 5, the Constitution empowers the Senate to write its own rules, but it does not stipulate the procedural requirements for ending debate and bringing the Senate to a vote. Downloads Download the Original Letter Authors Sarah A. BinderGregory KogerThomas E. MannNorman OrnsteinEric SchicklerBarbara SinclairSteven S. SmithGregory J. Wawro Publication: The United States Senate Image Source: © Kevin Lamarque / Reuters Full Article