of

New BMC commissioner Iqbal Singh Chahal takes official charge




of

Maharashtra CM refutes rumours of deploying Army in Mumbai




of

Coronavirus breaches White House as rest of America re-opens

Three aides working for US President Donald Trump, vice-president Mike Pence, and first daughter Ivanka Trump have tested positive for the novel coronavirus this week. This has brought the pandemic to within a degree of the center of power in the US.




of

Obama calls Trump's handling of pandemic a 'chaotic disaster'

Former president Barack Obama has launched a scathing attack on Donald Trump's handling of the coronavirus pandemic, calling it an "absolute chaotic disaster."




of

Paradise Papers: The moral dilemmas of tax avoidance

Mohan Guruswamy

The tranche of documents uncovered recently has not only brought several stalwarts of Indian politics, cinema industry, and business tycoons under scanner but has also thrown up pertinent questions over the moral dilemmas of avoiding tax

The paradise in the Paradise Papers refers to tax havens of low or even no taxation. Such havens usually are shadowy and sleazy little countries and principalities such as the Cayman Islands, Lichtenstein and Monaco, and sometimes entities within countries like Jersey, Guernsey, Bermuda in the UK and Delaware and Puerto Rico in the USA. Then there are low taxation countries like Switzerland, Singapore and Dubai that assure secretive rich people of their privacy. 

Essentially a tax haven exists to cheat sovereign states of their lawful incomes. The Tax Justice Network campaign group estimates that corporate tax avoidance costs governments $500bn a year, while personal tax avoidance costs $200bn a year. This in effect means that anywhere between $20-30 trillion of business transactions are sheltered from taxations. Moody’s estimated that in 2016 giant American technology companies such as Google, Microsoft and Apple were hoarding about $1.84 trillion cash in offshore havens. Clearly they are avoiding tax and as bending the rules of the tax system is not illegal unlike tax evasion; they are operating within the letter, but perhaps not the spirit, of the law.

In the early 1980’s, shaken up by the number of scandals in Wall Street, and by the number of its MBA graduates who were found wanting in ethical and moral values, the Harvard Business School made a course on “Leadership and Corporate Accountability” a core requirement. I am sure Jayant Sinha, a Harvard MBA, had to do this course and would have scored a high grade in it. Such courses now are in the core curriculum of the business schools attended by the other two young politicians also named in the Paradise Papers or capers if you will. Sachin Pilot graduated from the famous Wharton School of Business and Karti Chidambaram took his business masters from Texas and a law degree from Cambridge to boot.

Doing the required ethics course is one thing but it is quite something else to be able to resolve moral dilemmas of what John Kenneth Galbraith described as the “HBS’s ethical view of capitalism which derives straight out of the Protestant ethic and its transformational view of money, in which the ability to accumulate wealth is a reflection of one’s character.”

The charge against Jayant Sinha is that while acting as an Omidyar Network representative was on the board of a California company that made a loan to that company’s Cayman subsidiary. Usually such a loan to such a subsidiary suggests a fiddle. Whether Sinha knew this or did not know it is something else? Clearly the evidence does not suggest any malfeasance. But clearly there is room for skepticism. 

Omidyar Network proclaims its belief: “Just as eBay created the opportunity for millions of people to start their own businesses, we believe market forces can be a potent driver for positive social change.” Grand words but that hardly conceals the true goal that is to make bucks, sometimes fast ones too.  Again as Galbraith put it: “The modern conservative is engaged in one of man’s oldest exercises in moral philosophy; that is, the search for a superior moral justification for selfishness.”

Jayant, then fresh out of one of the IIT’s, worked with me way back in the mid 1980’s on a paper that proposed the mass construction of smokeless challahs for rural homes as a profitable employment for hundreds of thousands of rural workers. I remember it as a bit of an elaborate scheme that also computed the savings due to improved health results. It was published in this newspaper and the then Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi took note of it. I was impressed enough to write a recommendation when he applied for a Masters in Energy Management at Pennsylvania. 

I next met him when I was serving as his fathers Advisor in the Finance Ministry. Jayant and his wife were both working with foreign companies investing in Indian stocks. He was apprehensive about a proposal made by me to disinvest PSU stocks by selling them to the governments banks for onward restructure and disinvestment. The minister had clearly spoken to him. At that time too I wondered if the HBS’s core business ethics course would have seen conflict of interest issues in it? The minister however had plenty of flex in him.

To my mind tax avoidance is just as reprehensible as tax evasion. Sinha was too junior in the Finance Ministry to have expressed views on this. It would have been unlikely though for that is not the HBS way. The previous Finance Minister, himself a Harvard MBA, would not have any left footprints for young Sinha to tread on. Neither would the present lawyer Finance Minister. 

 

Lead Image: 




of

Only 2% of Covid-19 beds occupied in Karnataka

Karnataka’s efforts to slow the spread of coronavirus have ensured that healthcare systems are not overwhelmed with cases. This is evident from the low bed occupancy in dedicated Covid-19 hospitals. Ninety-eight per cent of the beds earmarked for coronavirus patients across the state are vacant.




of

‘Economy to see output loss of $190 bn’

FDI by firms moving from China to India will help offset damage: Kotak’s Shah




of

India set to cover the globe with exports of masks

‘Demand goes viral in the backdrop of COVID-19 pandemic




of

Rumour on issuance of token for train tickets creates furore

Workers rush to Tiruppur Railway Station, only to be disappointed




of

Minister visits site for relocation of Uddandapur reservoir oustees

‘Proper opportunities would be created for their livelihood’




of

Eatala kicks off Ayush kit distribution programme

About 20,000 kits to be distributed to policemen, healthcare workers in red zone areas, in first phase




of

Aid to poor through post offices from Monday

Special CorrespondentHyderabad




of

Petition in HC to reopen places of worship

A public interest litigation petition has been filed in the Madras High Court seeking a direction to the State government to permit reopening of templ




of

‘Virus warriors’ of Sikh body to get ₹2 lakh cover

The Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee (DSGMC) on Saturday announced an insurance cover of ₹2 lakh for its employees who are involved in frontli




of

Rs 1 lakh crore Delhi-Mumbai Expressway project offers huge investment opportunities: Gadkari

Rs 1 lakh crore Delhi-Mumbai Expressway project offers huge investment opportunities: Gadkari




of

Visakhapatnam gas leak: LG Polymers apologises, offers ‘every support’ to affected

Visakhapatnam gas leak: LG Polymers apologises, offers ‘every support’ to affected




of

Vizag gas leak: Chilling scenes bring back memories of Bhopal gas tragedy

Vizag gas leak: Chilling scenes bring back memories of Bhopal gas tragedy




of

SS Karthikeya walks out of his next venture

SS Karthikeya walks out of his next venture




of

Esports: Wehrlein ends Guenther's run of virtual Formula E success

Esports: Wehrlein ends Guenther's run of virtual Formula E success




of

Benin tests teachers for virus ahead of school restart

Benin tests teachers for virus ahead of school restart




of

Post-reopening cases in South Korea, Germany spark 2nd wave fears - Times of India

Post-reopening cases in South Korea, Germany spark 2nd wave fears - Times of India




of

Seven killed in protests over food distribution in Afghanistan, local MP says - Times of India

Seven killed in protests over food distribution in Afghanistan, local MP says - Times of India




of

‘Can’t afford to go back, & can’t afford to stay in UK’ - Times of India

‘Can’t afford to go back, & can’t afford to stay in UK’ - Times of India




of

Pakistan lifts lockdown even as Covid-19 cases surge - Times of India

Pakistan lifts lockdown even as Covid-19 cases surge - Times of India




of

Coronavirus breaches White House as rest of America re-opens

Coronavirus breaches White House as rest of America re-opens




of

Hong Kong: Trump administration tightens visas for Chinese reporters - Times of India

Hong Kong: Trump administration tightens visas for Chinese reporters - Times of India




of

Bombay HC adjourns PIL against enquiry into IPS officer over letter he wrote

Bombay HC adjourns PIL against enquiry into IPS officer over letter he wrote




of

Request for registering retailers, construction professionals as MSMEs to be examined: Gadkari

Request for registering retailers, construction professionals as MSMEs to be examined: Gadkari




of

ED attaches part of AJL's Rs 160cr Mumbai building - Times of India

ED attaches part of AJL's Rs 160cr Mumbai building - Times of India




of

ITC scam a pre-meditated loot of public money: HC

ITC scam a pre-meditated loot of public money: HC




of

Ahmedabad youth offers model for quicker detection

Ahmedabad youth offers model for quicker detection




of

Western parts of city report 14 fresh cases

Western parts of city report 14 fresh cases




of

More than half of all Shramik trains departed from Gujarat

More than half of all Shramik trains departed from Gujarat




of

April power bills can be paid by May 30 | Ahmedabad News - Times of India

April power bills can be paid by May 30 | Ahmedabad News - Times of India




of

Guj: 5 of family hacked to death over old enmity

Guj: 5 of family hacked to death over old enmity




of

Call of duty gets equal attention as her infant

Call of duty gets equal attention as her infant




of

Co-morbidity, late hospitalization ailing Gujarat: AIIMS chief | Ahmedabad News - Times of India

Co-morbidity, late hospitalization ailing Gujarat: AIIMS chief | Ahmedabad News - Times of India




of

Chennai: 356 passengers from Dubai quarantined | Chennai News - Times of India

Chennai: 356 passengers from Dubai quarantined | Chennai News - Times of India




of

As Chennai botches up, districts show way | Chennai News - Times of India

As Chennai botches up, districts show way | Chennai News - Times of India




of

Next batch of train passes to be issued after rush clears, say cops

Next batch of train passes to be issued after rush clears, say cops




of

Govt extends early bird scheme to commercial establishments | Hyderabad News - Times of India

Govt extends early bird scheme to commercial establishments | Hyderabad News - Times of India




of

'Next batch of train passes after rush clears'

'Next batch of train passes after rush clears'




of

Lockdown helps officials put road works across Hyderabad in the fast lane | Hyderabad News - Times of India

Lockdown helps officials put road works across Hyderabad in the fast lane | Hyderabad News - Times of India




of

A city-based session of meditation for world peace

A city-based session of meditation for world peace




of

Bengaluru: Two Covid-19 positive women give birth to 3 babies | Bengaluru News - Times of India

Bengaluru: Two Covid-19 positive women give birth to 3 babies | Bengaluru News - Times of India




of

Welcome indicator: Only 2% of Covid-19 beds occupied in Karnataka | Bengaluru News - Times of India

Welcome indicator: Only 2% of Covid-19 beds occupied in Karnataka | Bengaluru News - Times of India




of

Isolation over for 3,000 Jamaat members | Delhi News - Times of India

Isolation over for 3,000 Jamaat members | Delhi News - Times of India




of

Delhi: A month’s leaves, and Salman copes with lack of work

Delhi: A month’s leaves, and Salman copes with lack of work




of

Traders in Delhi worried about return of workforce | Delhi News - Times of India

Traders in Delhi worried about return of workforce | Delhi News - Times of India




of

Postal dept to release special cover on migrant workers of Mumbai

Postal dept to release special cover on migrant workers of Mumbai