Latest legislative news

legislative

Why legislative proposals to improve drug and device development must look beyond FDA approvals

By webfeeds.brookings.edu
Published On :: Tue, 28 Apr 2015 08:00:00 -0400

Legislative proposals to accelerate and improve the development of innovative drugs and medical devices generally focus on reforming the clinical development and regulatory review processes that occur before a product gets to market. Many of these proposals – such as boosting federal funding for basic science, streamlining the clinical trials process, improving incentives for development in areas of unmet medical need, or creating expedited FDA review pathways for promising treatments – are worthy pursuits and justifiably part of ongoing efforts to strengthen biomedical innovation in the United States, such as the 21^st Century Cures initiative in the House and a parallel effort taking shape in the Senate.

What has largely been missing from these recent policy discussions, however, is an equal and concerted focus on the role that postmarket evidence can play in creating a more robust and efficient innovation process. Data on medical product safety, efficacy, and associated patient outcomes accrued through routine medical practice and through practical research involving a broad range of medical practices could not only bolster our understanding of how well novel treatments are achieving their intended effects, but reinforce many of the premarket reforms currently under consideration. Below and in a new paper, we highlight the importance of postmarket evidence development and present a number of immediately achievable proposals that could help lay the foundation for future cures.

Why is postmarket evidence development important?

There are a number of reasons why evidence developed after a medical product’s approval should be considered an integral part of legislative efforts to improve biomedical innovation. First and foremost, learning from clinical experiences with medical products in large patient populations can allow providers to better target and treat individuals, matching the right drug or device to the right patient based on real-world evidence. Such knowledge can in turn support changes in care that lead to better outcomes and thus higher value realized by any given medical product.

Similarly, data developed on outcomes, disease progression, and associated genetic and other characteristics that suggest differences in disease course or response to treatment can form the foundation of future breakthrough medical products. As we continue to move toward an era of increasingly-targeted treatments, this important of this type of real-world data cannot be discounted.

Finally, organized efforts to improve postmarket evidence development can further establish infrastructure and robust data sources for ensuring the safety and effectiveness of FDA-approved products, protecting patient lives. This is especially important as Congress, the Administration, and others continue to seek novel policies for further expediting the pre-market regulatory review process for high-priority treatments. Without a reliable postmarket evidence development infrastructure in place, attempts to further shorten the time it takes to move a product from clinical development to FDA approval may run up against the barrier of limited capabilities to gather the postmarket data needed to refine a product’s safety and effectiveness profile. While this is particularly important for medical devices – the “life cycle” of a medical device often involves many important revisions in the device itself and in how and by whom it is used after approval – it is also important for breakthrough drugs, which may increasingly be approved based on biomarkers that predict clinical response and in particular subpopulations of patients.

What can be done now?

The last decade has seen progress in the availability of postmarket data and the production of postmarket evidence. Biomedical researchers, product developers, health care plans, and providers are doing more to collect and analyze clinical and outcomes data. Multiple independent efforts – including the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s Sentinel Initiative for active postmarket drug safety surveillance, the Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute’s PCORnet for clinical effectiveness studies, the Medical Device Epidemiology Network (MDEpiNet) for developing better methods and medical device registries for medical device surveillance and a number of dedicated, product-specific outcomes registries – have demonstrated the powerful effects that rigorous, systematic postmarket data collection can have on our understanding of how medical products perform in the real-world and of the course of underlying diseases that they are designed to treat.

These and other postmarket data systems now hold the potential to contribute to data analysis and improved population-based evidence development on a wider scale. Federal support for strengthening the processes and tools through which data on important health outcomes can be leveraged to improve evidence on the safety, effectiveness, and value of care; for creating transparent and timely access to such data; and for building on current evidence development activities will help to make the use of postmarket data more robust, routine, and reliable.

Toward that end, we put forward a number of targeted proposals that current legislative efforts should consider as the 2015 policy agenda continues to take shape:

Evaluate the potential use of postmarket evidence in regulatory decision-making. The initial Cures discussion draft mandated FDA to establish a process by which pharmaceutical manufacturers could submit real-world evidence to support Agency regulatory decisions. While this is an important part of further establishing methods and mechanisms for harnessing data developed in the postmarket space, the proposed timelines (roughly 12 months to first Guidance for Industry) and wide scope of the program do not allow for a thoughtfully-, collaboratively-considered approach to utilizing real-world evidence. Future proposals should allow FDA to take a longer, multi-stakeholder approach to identify the current sources of real-world data, gaps in such collection activities, standards and methodologies for collection, and priority areas where more work is needed to understand how real-world data could be used.

Expand the Sentinel System’s data collection activities to include data on effectiveness. Established by Congress in 2007, Sentinel is a robust surveillance system geared toward monitoring the safety of drugs and biologics. In parallel to the program for evaluating the use of RWE outlined above, FDA could work with stakeholders to identify and pursue targeted extensions of the Sentinel system that begin to pilot collection of such data. Demonstration projects could enable faster and more effective RWE development to characterize treatment utilization patterns, further refine a product’s efficacy profile, or address pressing public health concerns – all by testing strategic linkages to data elements outside of Sentinel’s safety focus.

Establish an active postmarket safety surveillance system for medical devices. Congress has already acted once to establish device surveillance, mandating in 2012 that Sentinel be expanded to include safety data on medical devices. To date, however, there has been no additional support for such surveillance or even the capability of individually tracking medical devices in-use. With the recently finalized Unique Device Identifier rule going effect and the ability to perform such tracking on the horizon, the time is now to adopt recent proposals from FDA’s National Medical Device Postmarket Surveillance System Planning Board. With Congressional authorization for FDA to establish an implementation plan and adequate appropriations, the true foundation for such a system could finally be put into place.

These next steps are practical, immediately achievable, and key to fully realizing the intended effect of other policy efforts aimed at both improving the biomedical innovation process and strengthening the move to value-based health care.

Why legislative proposals to improve drug and device development must look beyond FDA approvals

Authors

Uddhav Thackeray calls PM Narendra Modi, seeks help for nomination to Legislative Council

COVID-19: Government writes to ECI, seeks legislative council polls

Ahead of crucial Legislative Council election, Uddhav Thackeray pays 'courtesy' visit to Maharashtra Governor

The OECD Working Group on Bribery is concerned about potential political interference by the legislative branch in the independence of the judiciary in Slovenia

Poland must make urgent legislative reforms to combat foreign bribery

Chile must conclude its current legislative reforms of the criminal sanctions regime and clarify its corporate liability framework to better combat foreign bribery

Lithuania has made significant legislative reforms to fight foreign bribery and should now ensure effective anti-bribery enforcement

Poland must make urgent legislative reforms to combat foreign bribery

Maharashtra legislative council polls to held before May 27: Sources

CM Thackeray seeks PM Modi's help for nomination to Legislative Council

Uddhav Thackeray meets governor ahead of Legislative Council election

ECI allows Legislative Council elections in Maharashtra; all eyes on Uddhav

South Korea holds legislative election amid virus outbreak

Maha Cabinet Again Asks Governor Koshyari to Name CM Uddhav Thackeray as Member of Legislative Council

MVA Leaders Meet Governor, Request Him for Uddhav Thackeray's Entry Into Maha Legislative Council

After Uddhav's Call to PM Modi, Maharashtra Governor Asks EC to Hold Legislative Council Polls

Bihar Legislative Council Becomes Headless as Term of Deputy Chairman Along With 16 MLCs Expires

Maharashtra Governor BS Koshyari requests EC to conduct polls for 9 vacant Legislative Council seats

Legislative exemptions that allow faith-based educational institutions to discriminate against students, teachers and staff / The Senate, Legal and Constitutional Affairs References Committee

A guide to the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration : legislative history and commentary / by Howard M. Holtzmann and Joseph E. Neuhaus

Legal Research Reports: Continuity of Legislative Activities during an Emergency

Legal Research Reports: CORRECTION: Continuity of Legislative Activities during Emergency Situations

CRS Employment Opportunities: Legislative Attorney (Communications Law)

CRS Employment Opportunities: Analyst on Congress and the Legislative Process

CRS Employment Opportunities: Legislative Data Specialist

Legislative hardball: the house freedom caucus and the power of threat-making in Congress / Matthew N. Green

Survey results: Roundtable on Higher Education recommendations and potential legislative action for the North Dakota University System / prepared by the North Dakota University System at the request of Senator Holmberg, Chair, Roundtable on Higher Educat

Examining the Title X Family Planning Program's (Public Law 91-572) legislative history through a feminist lens

Central Florida Legislative Delegation, Ad Hoc Committee on Transportation : briefing materials

Florida Legislative Investigation Committee (Johns Committee) archive

The effectiveness of protection policies and legislative framework with special regard to karst landscapes: Insights from Slovenia

Canadian Legislative Pulse with Regulations

U.S. Master Tax Guide, 2013 - Legislative Update

2013 U.S. Master Tax Guide + the Legislative Update Combo

Deputy chairperson of Legislative Council seeks state-wide implementation of Pune ZP’s ‘PDS for undocumented’ scheme

Moving House Online: How crucial legislative work could continue in crisis

Human rights in legislative processes in focus at OSCE and OHCHR-supported training course for advisors and experts of Kyrgyz parliament

Ganababu, Chiranjeevi Rao appointed Whips in Legislative Assembly and Council respectively

Cornucopia of State Legislative RSS Feeds

Call for candidates for the Legislative Council

New report highlights regulatory and legislative action on workers’ comp

New report spotlights legislative actions on workers’ comp

Workers’ comp report looks at regulatory and legislative trends in 2024

Commission makes nearly 20 legislative recommendations to address Indiana’s behavioral health needs

Policast: The last week of the legislative session

Policast: Legislative session ends, but not for long

Minnesota legislative leaders highlight their party's values and issues

Expert Available: GOP Sets Sights on Legislative Agenda for Trump's First 100 Days

Marquis Who's Who Honors David G. Anderson for Expertise in Education, Government, and Legislative Relations

DWC Seeks Input on Legislative Recommendations

California Legislative, Regulatory, and Angelotti Update

Subscribe To Our Newsletter