Latest rn news

Aging the Internet Prematurely, One PDP at a Time

By wendy.seltzer.org
Published On :: 2007-07-01T07:15:51-05:00

After blogging about ICANN's new gTLD policy or lack thereof, I've had several people ask me why I care so much about ICANN and new top-level domains. Domain names barely matter in a world of search and hyperlinks, I'm told, and new domains would amount to little more than a cash transfer to new registries from those trying to protect their names and brands. While I agree that type-in site-location is less and less relevant, and we haven't yet seen much end-user focused innovation in the use of domain names, I'm not ready to throw in the towel. I think ICANN is still in a position to do affirmative harm to Internet innovation.

You see, I don't concede that we know all the things the Internet will be used for, or all the things that could be done on top of and through its domain name system. I certainly don't claim that I do, and I don't believe that the intelligence gathered in ICANN would make that claim either.

Yet that's what it's doing by bureaucratizing the addition of new domain names: Asserting that no further experiments are possible; that the "show me the code" mode that built the Internet can no longer build enhancements to it. ICANN is unnecessarily ossifying the Internet's DNS at version 1.0, setting in stone a cumbersome model of registries and registrars, a pay-per-database-listing, semantic attachments to character strings, and limited competition for the lot. This structure is fixed in place by the GNSO constituency listing: Those who have interests in the existing setup are unlikely to welcome a new set of competitors bearing disruptions to their established business models. The "PDP" in the headline, ICANN's over-complex "Policy Development Process" (not the early DEC computer), gives too easy a holdout veto.

Meanwhile, we lose the chance to see what else could be done: whether it's making domain names so abundant that every blogger could have a meaningful set on a business card and every school child one for each different face of youthful experimentation, using the DNS hierarchy to store simple data or different kinds of pointers, spawning new services with new naming conventions, or something else entirely.

I don't know if any of these individually will "add value." Historically, however, we leave that question to the market where there's someone willing to give it a shot. Amazingly, after years of delay, there are still plenty of people waiting in ICANN queues to give new gTLDs a try. The collective value in letting them experiment and new services develop is indisputably greater than that constrained by the top-down imaginings of the few on the ICANN board and councils, as by their inability to pronounce .iii.

"How do you get an answer from the web?" the joke goes: "Put your guess into Wikipedia, then wait for the edits." While Wikipedians might prefer you at least source your guess, the joke isn't far from the mark. The lesson of Web 2.0 has been one of user-driven innovation, of launching services in beta and improving them by public experimentation. When your users know more than you or the regulators, the best you can do is often to give them a platform and support their efforts. Plan for the first try to break, and be ready to learn from the experience.

To trust the market, ICANN must be willing to let new TLDs fail. Instead of insisting that every new business have a 100-year plan, we should prepare the businesses and their stakeholders for contingency. Ensuring the "stable and secure operation of the Internet's unique identifier systems" should mean developing predictable responses to failure, not demanding impracticable guarantees of perpetual success. Escrow, clear consumer information, streamlined processes, and flexible responses to the expected unanticipated, can all protect the end-users better than the dubious foresight of ICANN's central regulators. These same regulators, bear in mind, didn't foresee that a five-day add-grace period would swell the ranks of domains with "tasters" gaming the loophole with ad-based parking pages.

At ten years old, we don't think of our mistakes as precedent, but as experience. Kids learn by doing; the ten-year-old ICANN needs to do the same. Instead of believing it can stabilize the Internet against change, ICANN needs to streamline for unpredictability. Expect the unexpected and be able to act quickly in response. Prepare to get some things wrong, at first, and so be ready to acknowledge mistakes and change course.

I anticipate the counter-argument here that I'm focused on the wrong level, that stasis in the core DNS enhances innovative development on top, but I don't think I'm suggesting anything that would destabilize established resources. Verisign is contractually bound to keep .com open for registrations and resolving as it has in the past, even if .foo comes along with a different model. But until Verisign has real competition for .com, stability on its terms thwarts rather than fosters development. I think we can still accommodate change on both levels.

The Internet is too young to be turned into a utility, settled against further innovation. Even for mature layers, ICANN doesn't have the regulatory competence to protect the end-user in the absence of market competition, while preventing change locks out potential competitive models. Instead, we should focus on protecting principles such as interoperability that have already proved their worth, to enhance user-focused innovation at all levels. A thin ICANN should merely coordinate, not regulate.

Aging the Internet Prematurely, One PDP at a Time

Az Āsahʹmāyī tā Damāvand : safarnāmah

Siyāsat-i jināyī-i Afghānistān dar qibāl-i zanān-i bazahʹyīdah dar partaw-i asnād-i bayn al-milal = Criminal policy of Afghanistan on the women victims in accordance with the international documents

Tū kasī nīstī kih bargardī : majmūʻah-i shiʻr = You are not the one who returns

Bā taghayyur-i qiyāfah-i sarnivisht-i insān taghayyur namīkand

At the core and in the margins : incorporation of Mexican immigrants in two rural Midwestern communities

Crime and arrest patterns in Iowa, 1976-1982

RNA-Protein Complexes and Interactions Methods and Protocols

Comment le Livre s’est fait livre. La fabrication des manuscrits bibliques (ive-xve siècle) : bilan, résultats, perspectives de recherche : Actes du colloque international organisé à l’Université de Namur du 23 au 25 mai 2012

De l’ancien français au français moderne: Théories, pratiques et impasses de la traduction intralinguale

Espace sacré, mémoire sacrée. Le culte des évêques dans leurs villes (IVe-XXe siècle): Actes du colloque international de Tours 10-12 juin 2010

Forms of Individuality and Literacy in the Medieval and Early Modern Periods REMAINDER

La Formule au Moyen Âge II = Formulas in Medieval Culture II: Actes du colloque international de Nancy et Metz, 7-9 juin 2012 = Proceedings of the International Conference, Nancy and Metz, 7th-9th June 2012

Legati, delegati e l’impresa d’Oltremare (secoli XII-XIII) = Papal Legates, Delegates and the Crusades (12th-13th Century): Atti del Convegno internazionale di studi Milano, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, 9-11 marzo 2011

Rituals, Performatives, and Political Order in Northern Europe, c. 650–1350 REMAINDER

Town and Country in Medieval North Western Europe: Dynamic Interactions

Urban identities in Northern Italy, 800-1100 ca. REMAINDER

Starting over : The language development in internationally-adopted children

The Old English gloss to the Lindisfarne Gospels : language, author and context

Financial signal processing and machine learning

Inventing atmospheric science : Bjerknes, Rossby, Wexler, and the foundations of modern meteorology

Learn Adobe Illustrator CC for graphic design and illustration : Adobe Certified Associate exam preparation

Learning JavaScript : add sparkle and life to your web pages

Modern control systems

Sound systems : design and optimization : modern techniques and tools for sound system design and alignment

Data mining and machine learning in building energy analysis

John Vassos : industrial design for modern life

Make : FPGAs : turning software into hardware with eight fun and easy DIY projects

Modern Web development : understanding domains, technologies, and user experience

Our energy future : resources, alternatives and the environment

Waste management and valorization : alternative technologies

The bedrock geology of the Holderness Quadrangle, New Hampshire

Guide to the geology of northeastern North Dakota : including Cavalier, Grand Forks, Nelson, Pembina, and Walsh Counties

Guide to the geology of southeastern North Dakota, including Barnes, Cass, Griggs, Ransom, Richland, Sargent, Steele, and Traill Counties : an earth science guide for North Dakota school students

Guide to the geology of northwestern North Dakota : Burke, Divide, McLean, Mountrail, Renville, Ward, and Williams Counties

Guide to the geology of southwestern North Dakota : including Adams, Billings, Bowman, Dunn, Golden Valley, Grant, Hettinger, McKenzie, Mercer, Morton, Oliver, Sioux, Slope, and Stark Counties : an earth science guide for North Dakota school students

Guide to the geology of southwestern North Dakota : Adams, Billings, Bowman, Dunn, Golden Valley, Grant, Hettinger, McKenzie, Mercer, Morton, Oliver, Sioux, Slope, and Stark Counties

Guide to the geology of northeastern North Dakota : Cavalier, Grand Forks, Nelson, Pembina, and Walsh counties

Guide to the geology of southeastern North Dakota : Barnes, Cass, Griggs, Ransom, Richland, Sargent, Steele, and Traill counties

Distribution of sedimentary rocks in Montana and the northwestern Great Plains

Improving learning in secondary schools : conditions for successful provision and uptake of classroom assessment feedback

Hydrogeomorphic Risk Analysis Affecting Chalcolithic Archaeological Sites from Valea Oii (Bahlui) Watershed, Northeastern Romania An Interdisciplinary Approach

ISFRAM 2015 Proceedings of the International Symposium on Flood Research and Management 2015

[Full-time] Office Manager/ Marketing Associate (Maternity Cover) at HAS Advantage

Remove “External” tag from Outlook Message List

'How Wild' podcast explores the history of the wilderness and its future

NASA's Crew-8 mission members return to Earth on SpaceX capsule

Part 121 ERJ145 Dornier 328 Jet Captains job at Denver Air Connection in En

Part 121 ERJ145 Dornier 328 Jet Captains job at Denver Air Connection in En

Avionics Tech job at WESTERN PLAINS AVIATION LLC in Greeley CO

Alternatives to LEED

NCS Trust ‘sad and disappointed’ at government plans to shut it down

The Future of Morning Meals

New Karndean collection replicates the beauty of natural timber

EWR-DEL-BLR in UA J and AI (UK) C -- and a warning about crew rest on United 789s

Top 2024 Advances in Alternative Protein

Good Morning, News: City Council to Vote on Clean & Safe Contract, Vision Zero Gets an Audit, and Trump Taps Elon Musk to Lead DOGE (Do You Even Want to Know?)

Trump intends to nominate Florida Rep. Matt Gaetz as attorney general

Former heavywieght champ Mike Tyson to fight YouTuber-turned-boxer Jake Paul

Basic Black: Cornel West and Black Prophetic Fire

Watch autonomous cars do doughnuts and drift sideways round corners

Zelensky addresses Western allies after Russia strikes Kyiv

Famous Russian chef and journalist suddenly dies after preparing dinner in Belgrade

Un avance hacia medicamentos y vacunas inhalables de ARNm

AANA Calls on VA to Immediately Address Staffing Shortages and CRNA Practice Authority

Subscribe To Our Newsletter