land

'Error-strewn Ireland display may force Farrell into shake-up'

Ireland's error-filled performance in the 23-13 defeat by New Zealand leaves head coach Andy Farrell with much to ponder.




land

All you need to know about Ireland v Argentina

All you need to know as Ireland host Argentina in the Autumn Nations Series at Aviva Stadium in Dublin.




land

Devenny receives first Northern Ireland call-up

Crystal Palace midfielder Justin Devenny is called up to the Northern Ireland squad for the first time for the Nations League matches against Belarus and Luxembourg.




land

Ireland 'ready to bounce back' against Pumas - Hansen

Mack Hansen says Ireland will ignore "outside noise" in the build-up facing Argentina after their defeat to the All Blacks




land

Argentina make three changes for Ireland game

Argentina make three changes from their 50-18 win over Italy last weekend for Friday's meeting with Ireland in Dublin.




land

Mullan steps down from Ireland captaincy

Katie Mullan steps away from her captaincy duties with Ireland after an eight-year stint but will continue to play for her country.




land

Egypt stun England in world final

Second seeds Egypt upset tournament favourites England to win the Women's World Team Championship in France.




land

How Scotland's first fire brigade inspired the world

Modern fire brigades around the world were created after Edinburgh led the way 200 years ago.




land

Watch: Armistice Day tributes take place across Scotland

The traditional 11 November two-minute period of remembrance took place at 11:00 across the country.




land

Europe's largest inland surf resort opens in disused quarry

Lost Shore has a wave pool three times the size of Wembley football pitch - but how does it work?




land

Scotland's papers: Welby quits and Higher exam 'controversy'

A review of the front page stories from the daily newspapers in Scotland.




land

10 years of the plastic bag charge in Scotland

In 2014, shops started charging a minimum of 5p per bag in attempt to reduce waste.




land

Hunting For Ghosts In The Scottish Highlands...

The team join paranormal investigators to see if they can find a ghost




land

Highland Cops

Inverness CID battle the Liverpool drug gangs threatening the city.




land

Donald Trump's mother: From a Scottish island to New York's elite

Donald Trump's mother Mary Anne MacLeod grew up on the Hebridean island of Lewis.




land

Islanders face a difficult winter, warns minister

Transport Minister Fiona Hyslop says she is pushing ferry operator CalMac to consider "all options" to maintain services.




land

Highland tourist tax could raise £10m a year

Highland Council has proposed setting a 5% rate for its visitor levy.




land

Why has Northern Ireland not seen any sunshine recently?

Northern Ireland has been shrouded in cloud, with patches of drizzle, mist, and fog for more than a week.




land

Alex Salmond: The Man Who Changed Scotland

Those who knew him remember the man whose dream it was to lead Scotland to independence.




land

Why the clocks have gone back and this landmark is still wrong

As people across the UK roll their clocks back to GMT on Sunday morning, there's one clock that will always show the wrong time.




land

Evening to highlight on-island nursing degrees

Manx Care is set to outline the opportunities to start a nursing career by studying on the island.




land

Island 'very proud' of Cavendish's achievements

The Manx missile ended his record-breaking career with a victory in Singapore on Sunday.




land

Shetland

When a woman goes missing with her young son, Tosh and Calder set out to find them.




land

Landward

Dougie sets sail for Coll, and Cammy visits the abandoned Orkney island of Swona.




land

Scot gets dream job as lighthouse keeper on remote Australian island

Sandy Duthie's "dream job" involves solitude, a 160-year history, and a colony of little penguins.




land

Scots teenager lands butterfly youth champion role

Harris McCutcheon, 17, is representing Scotland on a new Butterfly Conservation panel.




land

The boy conquering Scotland's towering sea stacks

Aden Thurlow, 11, is believed to be the youngest person to lead climbs on Am Buachaille and Old Man of Stoer.




land

Could a new 113-mile trail spark a tourism boom in the south of Scotland?

Dozens of new tourist businesses are opening in the South of Scotland as visitors escape to the great outdoors.




land

Scotland remembers the fallen on Armistice Day

Scotland fell silent at 11:00 to commemorate those who died in conflicts around the world.




land

The Budget: Five questions for Scotland answered

Labour claims that public services require a £40bn increase in taxation and spending




land

Jersey signs agreement with Caribbean islands

Jersey aims to "strengthen ties within education, sport and culture" with Antigua and Barbuda.




land

States trial to help visually impaired islanders

The technology allows people to scan a code and get information on navigating buildings.




land

Traitors star completes 750-mile Scotland to Wales trek

Andrew Jenkins says his aim was to give hope to those feeling defeated.




land

Pub closure warning: Many landlords only make 12p a pint

The boss of Britain's biggest pubs group urges the chancellor to extend business rates relief.




land

Pub landlord fears Budget may cost him £24K a year

The new Labour government is expected to announce spending cuts and tax rises in Wednesday's Budget.




land

How England's largest 'fish motorway' actually works

It's taken two years to build and is 200m (656ft) long, but why does the River Trent need a fish pass?




land

Saints given permission to develop land

The land is located adjacent to two of Northampton Saints' existing training pitches.




land

Hundreds protest against Chagos Islands deal

Chagossians from Crawley are critical of an agreement between the UK and Mauritian governments.




land

National Trust land deal to bring 91,000 new trees

The National Trust aims to convert disused farmland in Sefton into a thriving woodland habitat.




land

Council to keep land Lex Greensill was set to buy

The council says instead of selling the land to Lex Greensill it wants to turn it into woodland.




land

Collaboration urged over island sewage spills

Anti-pollution campaigners joined Southern Water at a public meeting in Newport.




land

Anscombe gives Gatland 'million dollar question'

Wales head coach Warren Gatland is unsure if returning fly-half Gareth Anscombe could make it through to the 2027 World Cup.




land

Luton and Sunderland fined for mass confrontation

Luton and Sunderland are fined by the Football Association for a mass confrontation at the end of their Championship game last month.




land

Chris McCausland: 'Perception of people with disabilities is antiquated'

The comedian has been praised by students at the Royal National College for the Blind, where he studied.




land

Mary Queen of Scots landmark to be lit up for show

Workington Hall is famous for having provided shelter to Mary Queen of Scots.




land

West of England events mark Armistice Day

Events take place across the region to mark the armistice at the end of World War One.




land

West Midlands postcodes top uninsured drivers list

Parts of Birmingham, Wolverhampton, Walsall and Solihull feature in an annual hotspot list.




land

Earthy earns maiden England U21 call-up

Bristol City midfielder George Earthy called up to the England Under-21 squad for the first time after a series of withdrawals due to either injury or transitions into the senior squad.




land

Hyde Park Winter Wonderland 2024: A Guide To Visiting London's Huge Christmas Festival

When to go, what to see and how to save money.



  • London
  • Christmas in London
  • Winter Wonderland
  • christmas in London
  • HYDE PARK WINTER WONDERLAND
  • LONDON AT CHRISTMAS
  • WINTER WONDERLAND HYDE PARK
  • WINTER WONDERLAND TICKETS
  • WINTER WONDERLAND MAP
  • 2024
  • CHRISTMAS 2024

land

Why Scotland should not make sex work illegal

UPDATE: MSPs have voted that Grant's bill will have to go to consultation and will not be fast-tracked. Which is good news. But the fight is not over, and expect more to come when the consultation hits.

At the same time that the Moratorium 2012 campaign kicks off in London, spearheading a common-sense approach to sex work, there appears a bid in Scotland to try to make prostitution illegal. Just to recap: soliciting, running a brothel, and kerb crawling are already illegal (as too are trafficking and sexual exploitation of children). Exchanging sex for money at this point is not. Not yet.

Labour MSP Rhoda Grant claims "Scotland should become an unattractive market for prostitution and therefore other associated serious criminal activities, such as people trafficking for sexual exploitation, would be disrupted." Grant is, unfortunately, badly informed and wrong. I'm going to keep this one short and sweet because the points are pretty straightforward...

Scotland does not have a sex trafficking epidemic

Sex trafficking is the excuse frequently given these days to harass and criminalise sex workers. Problem is, it's not remotely the "epidemic" they would have you believe. If you're not already up to speed on the whys and wherefores, I highly recommend reading Laura Agustin's work on this. Or if I may be so cheeky to suggest you could also buy my book. 

Specifically, it is not happening in Scotland“In Scotland, to the best of my knowledge, we don't have a conviction for human trafficking,” said police constable Gordon Meldrum. Meldrum had previously claimed research “proved” the existence of 10 human trafficking groups north of the border, and 367 organised crime groups with over 4000 members. “We had one case which was brought to court previously but was abandoned. My understanding is it was abandoned due to a lack of evidence, essentially.” Strange how the evidence seemed to disappear precisely when someone was asked to produce all these fantasy baddies, isn't it? 

It's not only Scotland where the trafficking hype falls flat though: investigation throughout the UK has comprehensively failed to find any supposed sex trafficking epidemic.

Not convinced by the evidence? Then consider this: criminalising sex workers and their clients removes the most reliable information sources police have for investigating abuses. Police don't have a great track record on this: In interviews by the Sex Workers Project with 15 trafficking survivors who experienced police raids, only one had been asked by law enforcement if she was coerced, and only after she was arrested. SWOP-NYC make this case clearly.

Criminalising sex work has been shown in Scotland to make criminal activity worse

Criminalisation has all kinds of effects on the behaviour of sex workers, but unfortunately, none of those effects are good. Fear of police forces sex workers to get into clients’ cars quickly, and possibly be unable to avoid dangerous attackers posing as clients. When vigilantes and police roam the pavements, sex workers wait until the wee hours to come out, making them more isolated and vulnerable to harm.

Such an approach can also result in a transfer of activity from streetwalking to other ways of getting money. High-profile crackdown results in repeated arrests of prostitutes, which translate to fines that sex workers, now burdened with criminal records, are unable to pay except by more prostitution or by fraud, shoplifting, and dealing drugs.

Take Aberdeen, for instance. From 2001 onward, the city had an established tolerance zone for sex workers around the harbour. That ended with passage of the Prostitution (Public Places) (Scotland) Act in 2007. In the following months the city centre experienced an influx of streetwalkers and an increase in petty crimes.

Quay Services, which operates a drop-in centre for streetwalkers, reported that sex workers became more afraid to seek assistance, and the number of women coming to the centre dropped to “just a handful”. There was also evidence that displacing sex workers led to more activity in the sex trade, not less – convictions for solicitation tripled.

This kind of ‘crime shuffling’ takes prostitution out of one area and dumps it on another. It only resembles an improvement if you fail to look at the full picture.

Prohibition never works

There is a lot of talk in the political sphere about the need for “evidence based policy”. This means rejecting approaches that are moralistic and manipulative. Sex workers have suffered the tragic consequences of prejudicial social attitudes that lead to bad policy. The prohibition approach has not worked. It will never work. The people who endorse this view are putting people in danger and should not be guiding public opinion any longer. Disliking sex work is not a good enough argument to justify criminalising it. Is there any public interest served by preventing adults from engaging in a consensual transaction for sexual services? No, there is not.

Bit like the war on drugs: making the business profitable only to criminals, awaiting the inevitably grim results, then claiming that it’s the drugs themselves, not the laws, wot caused it. Few reasonable people believe that line of argument when it comes to drugs. Why does anyone believe it when it comes to sex?

Moral disapproval is a bad basis for policymaking. I don't find the idea of taking drugs at all appealing, but I don't assume my own preferences should be the basis for law.

The condescension heaped on people who do sex work is embarrassingly transparent. All this mealy-mouthed, 'oh but we want to help them, really’. How’s that again? By saddling people with criminal records and taking away their children? Do me a favour.

As well as the happy prostitutes there are unhappy sex workers in need of support. Society should protect the unwilling and underage from sexual exploitation and provide outreach for those who need and want it. We already have laws and services for that. Maybe the laws should be more intelligently enforced and the services better supported. But prosecuting the victimless crimes does neither of these. It helps no one.

The potential existence of abuses does not mean such work should be automatically criminalised if for no other reason than doing so makes the lives of people in sex work worse, not better. Criminalisation is the very opposite of compassion. Rhoda Grant is hiding behind an "end demand" approach that will not achieve what she claims it will, but will punish sex workers and send those with already chaotic lives further into a downward spiral. If that isn't punishing them with no hope for change then I don't know what is.

It's time we started acting like grownups and stopped pretending that making something illegal makes it cease to exist.